
A major new series from Imprint Academic on the use of randomisation in education, politics and other public policy areas. Special discount prices for OurKingdom and openDemocracy readers.
Part of the openDemocracy Network
Sortition and public policyLabour After BrownFrom Milibland to Johnson land?: Jeremy Gilbert argues for Labour without neo-liberalism. Magical thinking on Britishness: Anthony Barnett critiques Liam Byrne on fraternity. Rule of law at risk: Geoffrey Bindman calls for a turn away from the marketisation of government. A new Bill of Rights for Britain?: Guy Aitchison analyses Parliament's proposed new Bill of Rights. Miliband - by our rights we will know you: Claire O'Brien puts forward a new progressive vision for Labour. NOT A DAY LONGER
England Awakes?England, Britain and multiculturalism: an OurKingdom exchange A mild awakening?, England's turn? by David Goodhart OurKingdom TagsNavigation |
Loss of Liberty and Rights since 1997This is the list of losses of liberty and rights since 1997 which Henry Porter submitted to the JCHR on Monday and we wrote about here. The list is a work in progress - is there anything you think should be added? If so, please let us know in the comments below. Feel free to post the list on your own blog, and link back here. Protest and assembly- Protests are banned within one kilometre of Parliament Square without police permission (penalty: 51 weeks in jail and/or a £2,500 fine). - Groups may be dispersed under antisocial-behaviour laws. - Groups may be dispersed within designated areas under the terror laws. - The new offence under SOCPA of trespass within a designated site (no justification for designation is required). Communications- Under the Regulation of Investigative Powers Act, government agencies may intercept email, internet connections and standard mail without seeking a court's permission (the latest figure is 500,000 secret interceptions a year). - Since summer 2007, the government and some 700 agencies have had access to all landline and mobile-phone records. There was no primary legislation and no debate in parliament. Databases- Without primary legislation, police introduced a national network of all ANPR cameras. The travel data may be stored for two years. - The National Identity Register will store details of every verification made by an ID-card holder and give access to government agencies without the knowledge or consent of the private citizen. - ID-card enrolment requires every citizen to offer up 49 piece of personal information to the national database, with heavy and repeated fines for non-compliance. - All children details are to be stored on a central database, with access granted to a wide range of public bodies. - The Children's Common Assessment Framework database stores all details of children with problems, indefinitely. - The Home Office has announced that it wishes to take 19 pieces of information, including mobile-phone and credit-card numbers, from everyone travelling abroad. Free Expression- Public-order laws have been used to curtail free expression. A man wearing the slogan "Bollocks to Blair" on his T-shirt was told to remove it by police. - The Race and Religious Hatred Act (2006) bans incitement of hatred on religious grounds. - Justice Minister Jack Straw proposes new laws which would ban the incitement of hatred towards the disabled and on the grounds of a person's sexual orientation - Terror laws are used to ban freedom of expression in designated areas. Walter Wolfgang was removed from the Labour party conference for heckling Jack Straw. People have been searched simply for wearing slogans on their T-shirts or for carrying banners. A man was detained while collecting signatures against the ID card - The Protection from Harassment Act (1997) bans the repetition of an act. People prosecuted for repeated protest by email. - Terror laws ban the glorification of terrorism, which has resulted in the prosecution of a young woman for writing poetry. The Courts- ASBO legislation introduces hearsay evidence, which may result in a person being sent to jail. - The Criminal Justice Act (2003) allows the prosecution to make an application to be heard without a jury where there is a danger of jury tampering. This will include fraud trials. - The admissibility of evidence concerning a person's bad character, previous convictions and acquittals. - The Proceeds of Crime Act (2002) gives the state powers to confiscate assets in circumstances where it does not have enough evidence for prosecution. -Special Immigration Appeals Court hearings are held in secret. Those terror suspects whose cases come before the court are not allowed to know the evidence against them or to be represented by a lawyer of their own choice. - The Courts and Tribunals Enforcement Act abandons the tradition of an Englishman's home being his castle, which since 1604 has made breaking into a home by bailiffs illegal. Terror Laws- Terror laws have been used to stop and search ordinary citizens. The current rate is 50,000 per annum. - A maximum of 28 days without charge is allowed under terror legislation. The government has announced plans to increase this to 42 days. - Control orders, effectively indefinite house arrest, were introduced after the Belmarsh decision. In thruth, all absolutley true. Well meaning fools rushing in to 'save everybody from themselves' and the 'Big Cruel World' end up implementing 'half baked' legislation that any future Petty Minded Vindictive government will use, and use to the full. Truly was Mr Blair, and now Mr Brown - are they they 'New Big Brother?' All this legislation must be repealed by the Conservatives at the next General election, or 'down the pan we will all go!' The spouses of Brtish citizens resident in Thailand are denied a free visa upon demand to visit the UK and instead have to make representations to the embassy in Bangkok in person, even if you are 1000klm away and if accepted have to pay a large fee for the privelige of visiting their spouses country, meanwhile every Pole and his dog gets to come to the UK for free as do any Americans, Australians Canadians etc. you get the picture.... The irony, if a Brit approaches any other EU country they get a free visa upon receipt of a marriage cert. So, massive discrimination against a section of British citizens and their families that never gets publicised, maybe it's because the Brits concerned are mainly white and what hope have whites today, not being a minority, which is what counts I'm told. Eavedropping on emails and telephone conversations including 'Scanning' of emails for particular words. It will shortly be possible to scan 'web browsing' on a massive scale. Yes I would agree that NU Labour [New Marxist Peril Party] under B'Liar and now under Pa McHasbeen Brown are the most useless, control-freaked out government the UK has had the missfortunate to have since the end of WW2. During 30 or so years of IRA terrorism, no UK government, Conservative or Labour ever passed the legislation we have now. Under the current legislation, anyone who the Govenment decides is a 'Threat' like Mr Walter Wolfgang a WW2 survivor, gets treated like he was an International Criminal. If I or anyone complains to a Government Quango, Local Government by Enail or letter, then we can be deemed as 'Criminals' for harrassing poor Civil Servants or MPs. What has this coutnry descended to. Nu Labour [ NU Peril Party] have enacted more legislation in 10 years than any other Labour or Conservative government has in the past 40 years or so. Why? Why Now? And just what is wrong with Mr Browns NU Labour Party -- are they truly infected with 'Collective Control Freakism'? Or are they all suffering from 'Big Shotism' and 'Massive Egos?' Once upon a time, perhaps in my imagination, the UK was a byword for human rights. However, this brief period of freedom, between Wilson and Thatcher (hag extraoridaire) the UK has lapsed back into the swamp of illiberalism that has characterised most of its history. The important thing is to believe in the myth of freedom, so recently debunked in the US, and insist upon increasing it by fighting against all the little maggots who are busily eating it away. The key fact is that politicians and public servants are just that, servants of the people. If they do not act accordingly then roll out the tumbrils. An interesting list but what about the omission?
The most glaring being the loss of Freedom of Speech at Work. Take the case of Karen Reissmann a Psychiatric Nurse for 25 years and Trade Union rep,she was sacked last year by the appalling Manchester Mental Health Care Trust. Her crime was to voice her concerns about the privatisation of Mental Health Services and the affect upon vulnerable patients of reorganisations. The gagging of workers happening all over the country and especially in the NHS where catch all "breach of contract", "bringing the Trust into disrepute", "Compromising the Trust" etc is used to shut up anyone who speaks out. Flouting any ideas that we are entitled to free speech. The gutless Labour Party encourages it of course. I am surprised that Mr Porter does not take up these most important breaches of civil liberties. Then again Mr Porter never mentions the anti Trade Union Laws, that basically remove the right to strike whenever and in support of whomsoever we chose. Could there be some class bias in Mr Porters choice of laws one rule for the Liberal intelligentsia and the wealthy and another for the many working people? How about English people being stripped of the right to vote on policies for Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland; while voters in those countries retain the right to vote on English matters? Concomitant to that: English people being deprived of democratically accountable government, as they can no longer vote out all those responsible for making laws and policies that apply to England alone. David, aka Britology Watch During a recent research project on behalf of the Ministry of Justice Professor C Thomas let slip the comment that the Department may consider embedding monitors in the jury suite during trial deliberations by the jury. Sinister, or what? Can you imagine how twelve jurors, good and true, would be inhibited by the presence of 'the government man'? The very fact that the comment was actually made is further indication of this governments determination to control every aspect of our lives, including the dispensation of thoughtful judgement on others. There are so many questions that this raises that it is impossible to articulate here other than to say that this idea must be campaigned against. Thanks gmonk, very helpful. It is imp to be alert to what indeed might be a softening up. Anthony Anthony: Sorry, there is no link on this comment as far as I am aware. The only thing I can say is that this actually happened, I was one of the excercise jurors in the jury suite where this occurred. I have e-mailed Jon Bright giving him the pertinanent details. I also e-mailed Tony Benn who gave me advice on the subject. Further to this I wrote a note to the Professor in the hope that she might give a response. This she has, to date, failed to do. It is, of course, quite possible that the comment was simply a musing of the good lady to sound out the representatives of justice and learn their feelings on the matter. However, and this is what worries me, she is close to those in the Ministry and must have a pretty clear idea of their mindset and if it was a feeler it must have had the approval of these people. Noting the very nature and objectives of this website it seemed to me to be appropriate to write in and also to highlight, once again, just how untrustworthy this particular bunch of politicians are turning out to be. Many of our freedoms have been subverted and all in the name of New Labour's obsession with globalisation and "modernity", in effect Blair's war cry. gmonk: can you give us a link or reference to this. Many thanks Anthony The right to free tertiary education? See tuition / top-up fees timeline. Introduced by people who all benefited from free university education and grants. [...] a list of liberties lost since 1997 see Our Kingdom (this is a work in progress so do feel free to add to the list). Share [...] I don't see any reference here to the 2003 UK/US Extradition treaty, which effectively makes UK citizens liable to US law and extradition to the USA without the need for prima facie evidence being placed before a UK court (but not, of course, vice versa). This treaty was put in place via an Order in Council without Parliamentary oversight or debate. I believe Nu labour has repealed all laws on treason because it was an offence to sign away the monarch's legitmate powers to another government or authorty. If any member of the government had signed away these powers to Brussells whilst these laws were in force the signatories would have been guilty of treason as adults we've lost alot of rights, but what about children and young people who can't vote?...under ASB legislation, they've.... lost the right to be outsite in groups of more than 2 people, can be dispersed by the police will have comitted a crime if they break conditions of their ASBO, that, as mentioned above, can be completely based on hearsay. and if they're over 12, can have their photo published in a newspaper, along with conditions of their ASBO, encouraging the public to report breaches of the conditions... What about the right to vote for true democratic political representation? As far as the English go, they've been politically disenfranchised for a decade! What about the right to drink in our own English pubs? What about the right to bring your kids up as you see fit? No not noise control but control by noise. What next? 'Mosquito to bite back against yobs Police in the Staffordshire Moorlands have been using their lates weapon in the fight against anti-social behaviour. The Mosquito device - which emits a high-ptched whistle has been installed outside business premises at Werrington following successful deployment of the device in Brown Edge and Endon. The use of the Mosquito has resulted in a reduction in nuisance behaviour in the Moorlands and after buying one of the devices the police have bought three more. The location at Werrington which is being kept secret has been chosen as a result of complaints from residents and businesses. Inspector Mark Rigby, head of Cheadle Police, which includes Werrington, said: "It has had some success, but not 100%.' http://www.compoundsecurity.co.uk/deterrent_news_27.html Would we be in this trouble of we still had the right to bear arms. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0gk9sABtJxM&eurl=http://www.wearechange.org.uk/ We British need to Unite. Birth Certificates, the Global Elite Own you and your children. http://youtube.com/watch?v=lOSgS9odK8s&feature=related [...] of security obsession and curtailment of Civil Liberties in which we now live - Our Kingdom have a little list that goes back to [...] Post new comment |
Just Posted
Just Commented
Email AlertsFill in the form below to sign up to our automatic daily alerts, or weekly editorial summary (you will be taken to another page to confirm which options you want).
OK is reading
They say about OK"the ever-stimulating OpenDemocracy"
Ekklesia "See OurKingdom to keep up" South Belfast Diary "...an essential guide to understanding the dynamic constitutional situation..." Peter Oborne "...becoming a daily read for me." Iain Dale "To make sense of it all, check out OurKingdom..." Matthew d'Ancona "Worth a look...it is, however, recommended by Matthew d'Ancona." The Wardman Wire "Fast becoming the best political website around" Tom Waterhouse, CEP "...attracting energy from a range of contributors." thenextwave "...looks very promising..." The England Project "The excellent new OurKingdom blog from OpenDemocracy..." The Green Ribbon "On the internet, I keep in touch with openDemocracy, a website on global current affairs, and its useful offshoot, OurKingdom" Andreas Whittam-Smith "thanks to the fine folk at OurKingdom, (who manage to communicate a variety of perspectives in the way that only a decent group blog can)" Nostalgia For the Future |
Suzy Dean (not verified) said:
Fri, 2008-03-07 12:31Many losses have been to do with our private life since 1997:
not being able to smoke in bars
not being able to speak on the mobile whilst driving and increasingly not being able to smoke whilst driving either (at the moment it's at police discretion)
tobacco advertising and sponsorship
hunting with hounds
smacking
fur farming
fizzy drinks in schools
using fireworks late at night
children being out alone in the evening
live entertainment